How to Avoid Common Digital Marketing Mistakes During the Holidays

Ah, the holidays—a magical time of year when inboxes overflow with “unmissable deals,” and businesses everywhere scramble to capture shoppers' attention. For marketers, it’s a season of both opportunity and stress. Nail your holiday campaigns, and you could be toasting record-breaking sales. Misstep, and you might end up with a lump of coal in your analytics dashboard (we had to—sorry).

The truth is, holiday marketing isn’t just about throwing some snowflakes on your logo and calling it a day. It’s a fierce competition with tight deadlines and savvy consumers who’ve seen every trick in the book. But fear not—this blog is here to help you out.

We’re breaking down the most common digital marketing mistakes businesses make during the holidays—and how to avoid them like a pro. Ready to sleigh your campaigns this season (we really can’t be stopped)? Let’s dive in.

Ignoring Mobile Users

Here’s a stat to remember: Smartphones constitute around 77% of retail site traffic globally and generate two-thirds of online shopping orders. That means if your website, ads, or emails aren’t optimized for mobile, you’re essentially telling half your audience, “Nah, we’re good without your business.”

The Mistake:

Failing to prioritize mobile users can lead to clunky layouts, slow-loading pages, and forms that feel impossible to fill out without an engineering degree. Nothing says “holiday fail” like a checkout page that crashes right when someone’s trying to buy Aunt Susan that perfect sweater.

The Solution:

Make mobile optimization your new best friend. Start with a responsive design that adapts across devices. Test your site and campaigns on smartphones and tablets to ensure everything runs smoothly. Don’t forget to check the nitty-gritty details—like button sizes, load times, and how your emails look in mobile inboxes.

Pro Tip:

Think mobile-first. Design your content with smaller screens in mind and then scale up for desktops. This approach ensures your mobile users get a seamless, fast experience—because nothing ruins holiday cheer like pinching and zooming on a tiny screen.

Remember, if your customers can’t easily shop or engage with your brand on mobile, they won’t think twice about moving on to one of your competitors who can. And that’s a gift no marketer wants to give away.

Overloading Audiences With Promotions

We get it—it’s the holidays, and you’ve got deals hotter than a freshly baked gingerbread cookie. But here’s the thing: Bombarding your audience with nonstop “BUY NOW!” messages isn’t festive; it’s fatiguing. Nobody wants to feel like their inbox is on your naughty list.

The Mistake:

Sending excessive promotions without a break can lead to email unsubscribes, ad fatigue, and a reputation as “that brand.” Overloading your audience isn’t just annoying—it’s a fast track to being ignored, no matter how great your deals are.

The Solution:

Focus on quality over quantity. Yes, your promotions matter, but mix them with value-driven content that resonates with your audience. Share helpful gift guides, festive how-tos, or feel-good stories about your brand. Striking this balance keeps your audience engaged instead of overwhelmed.

Pro Tip:

Segmentation is your holiday hero. Group your audience based on their interests, past purchases, or browsing behavior, and tailor your messages accordingly. Personalized campaigns that say, “We know what you love,” work far better than blanket blasts that scream, “We’re just here to sell you stuff.”

Don’t forget that the holidays are about building connections, not just sales. When your audience feels like you’re giving them value and not just shouting into the void, they’re far more likely to hit “add to cart.”

Neglecting Social Media Engagement

Social media during the holidays can be chaotic, but plenty of connections can still be made. However, if you’re just scheduling posts and ghosting your audience, you’re missing out on the real magic: engagement.

The Mistake:

Treating social media like a bulletin board instead of a conversation. Simply posting and walking away means leaving comments, questions, and potential customer relationships hanging. And trust us, nothing says “holiday humbug” like a brand that ignores its followers.

The Solution:

Stay active and responsive. Create engaging, festive content that gets people talking—think holiday polls, behind-the-scenes looks at your team’s celebrations, or fun giveaways. When followers comment or message, respond quickly and warmly. This isn’t just customer service; it’s community building.

Pro Tip:

Holiday hashtags and user-generated content are your secret weapons. Use trending holiday-themed hashtags (#HolidayDeals, #GiftGuide2024) to boost visibility and encourage your audience to share their own photos featuring your products. Reposting their content builds trust and makes your feed feel like a joyful, interactive celebration.

Social media isn’t just about likes and shares—it’s about creating moments that make your audience feel seen, valued, and connected to your brand. And that’s a holiday gift everyone appreciates.

Forgetting to Track Performance

Imagine baking holiday cookies without tasting the dough. Sure, you might get lucky, but there’s a good chance those cookies won’t be as delicious as they could be. The same logic applies to your holiday marketing campaigns—if you’re not tracking performance, you’re flying blind.

The Mistake:

Launching your holiday campaigns and hoping for the best without checking how they’re actually doing. This “set it and forget it” approach can lead to wasted budget, missed opportunities, and underwhelming results.

The Solution:

Make real-time tracking your holiday mantra. Set up analytics tools to monitor key metrics like click-through rates, conversion rates, and ROI. If something isn’t working, you’ll know early enough to pivot and save your campaign.

Pro Tip:

Leverage A/B testing to fine-tune your strategies on the fly. Test different ad creatives, subject lines, or audience segments to see what resonates most. Treat your campaigns like a recipe—adjust the ingredients until they’re just right.

By keeping a close eye on your campaign’s performance, you’ll catch what’s working (and what’s not) before it’s too late. After all, the holidays are all about making adjustments—whether it’s adding more frosting to cookies or tweaking your strategy to boost sales.

Failing to Prepare for Increased Demand

Picture this: your holiday campaign is a smash hit. Customers are clicking, shopping, and filling their carts—and then boom. Your website crashes, or worse, you sell out of your most popular products without a backup plan. Yikes.

The Mistake:

Underestimating just how much traffic and demand the holiday season can bring. This can lead to slow-loading websites, frustrated shoppers, and inventory issues that leave customers empty-handed (and not in a festive mood).

The Solution:

Get your digital and operational house in order before the holiday rush. Start with load testing your website to ensure it can handle traffic spikes without crashing.

Then, double-check that your inventory management systems are ready to track and update stock levels in real-time. And don’t forget your customer service team—make sure they’re prepared for an uptick in inquiries and ready to handle the occasional (or frequent) holiday meltdown.

Pro Tip:

Set up alerts for inventory levels so you can quickly restock bestsellers. For your website, consider investing in a content delivery network (CDN) to speed up load times for users around the globe. And as a safety net, have a clear plan to communicate with customers if there’s a hiccup—like a friendly, transparent email if shipping delays occur.

The holidays are a time for joy, not technical glitches. When you prepare for increased demand, you’ll not only keep your customers happy—you’ll also avoid being the brand everyone complains about while sipping their cocoa.

Not Retargeting Visitors Effectively

Fun fact: Most holiday shoppers don’t convert on their first visit to your site. They browse, they add to their cart, and then—poof—they’re gone. Maybe it was dinner time, maybe their cat walked across the keyboard, or maybe they were just waiting to see if a better deal came along. Whatever the reason, if you’re not retargeting those visitors, you’re leaving money (and potential sales) on the table.

The Mistake:

Letting potential customers slip through the cracks by not following up. Without retargeting ads or email reminders, you’re relying on them to remember you—which, let’s be honest, isn’t a safe bet during the busiest shopping season of the year.

The Solution:

Set up retargeting campaigns to gently nudge those visitors back to your site. Whether it’s a well-timed ad or a friendly email saying, “Hey, you left something in your cart,” retargeting keeps your brand top of mind. And during the holidays, that little nudge can make all the difference.

Pro Tip:

Sweeten the deal with an exclusive holiday offer. A small discount, free shipping, or even a festive “last chance to order!” reminder can be just the push they need to hit “buy now.” Bonus points if you add a touch of urgency—like a countdown timer or a “limited stock” note.

Retargeting isn’t just smart—it’s essential. The holidays are a whirlwind, and sometimes shoppers need a little reminder to come back and finish what they started. Make it easy for them, and you’ll turn those almost-sales into actual sales faster than you can say “holiday magic.”

Let Our Pros Make Your Campaign a Hit!

The holiday season is a golden opportunity for your brand—but it’s also a time when mistakes can quickly snowball (pun intended). From failing to optimize for mobile users to overlooking social media engagement, these missteps can derail your efforts quick.

But the good news? Avoiding these pitfalls is entirely doable with a little preparation and a lot of smart strategy. Engage thoughtfully, track your performance, and make sure your website is ready for the spotlight. Sprinkle in a dash of retargeting magic and some holiday-specific content, and you’ve got a recipe for success.

Truth is, the holidays are about more than just sales—they’re about connecting with your audience in meaningful ways. So, put your customers first, keep things festive, and don’t be afraid to think outside the (gift) box.

Feeling overwhelmed or need a helping hand? We’re here to make your holiday campaigns a hit. Reach out to us today to get started!

Looking to get started on your marketing upswing? We're offering 25% off any new service for the first three months, but you gotta talk to us before the end of the year!